American’s Real Concerns About The Public Option
Written by PeacockWatch on October 13, 2009.
Keith Olbermann’s recent hour long monologue about the horrors of our American health care system was a political rant in favor of the public option. One can understand his concern for his father and his desire to have a health system that could have extended his father’s life. We all understand that whether or not we have lost a loved one to sickness. Keith Olbermann has our sincere condolences for the horrible loss he has suffered.
We readily agree that health care is about improving the odds of life. At least in the term that has been allotted to us. Eventually the odds of life for all of us are zero.
We strongly disagree that a government health care program will improve the odds of life in the short term, we disagree that it is the responsibility of the government to assure our health, and we disagree that the current health insurance system is stylized blackmail. In fact, we disagree with Olbermann on almost everything except for his compassion for those who are sick and for those who have suffered the loss of those they love.
Olbermann, and MSNBC in general do not understand, or do not want to understand, why it is that most of us oppose what is called the public option. On the other hand, maybe they do understand but have become the conscious spin merchant in the media world for the public option.
Most Americans do not want the public option because most Americans no longer have full trust and faith in our government. Olbermann says health is not about politics. Of course it is about politics when you put the health plan in control of politicians! How clear can that be? Put the health plan in control of politicians by putting it under the public option and the health of all of us will be under the control of politicians who base their decisions on what they need to do to get enough votes to stay in office. Our health will always be secondary to that for most of our elected politicians. The evidence is too strong for most Americans to believe anything else.
We still have not heard of any federal government legislator who is unhappy with their own nationwide smorgasboard menu of health plans. They have had their special health plan for decades and never complain. If they truly cared about their constituents they would have been arguing for all of us to have the same plan they enjoy long long ago. Or, if they thought that the currently proposed public option would have been better for them they would have voted it in for themselves sometime in the middle of the 20th century.
Olbermann claims there is misunderstanding about the public option. How insulting can he be? Probably about as insulting as the federal “public servants” who keep claiming that the majority of Americans are in favor of the public option. The truth is that most Americans understand perfectly. We understand that our federal government is already too intrusive in our lives and has too much control over all of us. We understand that sending more money to Washington under the guise of a public option increases the government’s power and dramatically increases the government’s visibility into the most intimate details of our lives and the lives of those we love.
Olbermann claims that the proponents of the public option are being “out terrorized” by the opponents. He asks what the opponents are afraid of . The answer is simple. We are afraid that our federal government has become too powerful over our individual lives and that the public option will increase that power dramatically. To put it succinctly, we are becoming afraid of our government. Every move the White House and the legislature make increases the power of Washington and increases our taxes while decreasing our liberties.
Thomas Jefferson said, “A wise and frugal government, which shall leave men free to regulate their own pursuits of industry and improvement, and shall not take from the mouth of labor the bread it has earned – this is the sum of good government.”
The public option, by Jefferson’s definition, is bad government!



